pregnant woman talking at home

She Chose an Irish Name for Her Son, But Her Friend’s Reaction Put Their Friendship to the Ultimate Test.

In a tale of friendship tested by cultural boundaries and personal desires, the Original Poster (OP), an American, faces unexpected backlash after choosing a traditional Irish name for her son, deeply offending her closest Irish friend. As OP anticipates her friend’s joy at the intended tribute, the atmosphere takes a sharp turn, plunging them both into a whirlwind of emotions and severed communication. Yet, beneath the surface conflict, deeper issues of identity, cultural appropriation, and the profound significance of names emerge, leaving the future of their bond hanging in the balance.

The American and the Irish

women together arms around
image credit: icons8/canva

OP and her close friend, an Irish woman, met in college. Their bond deepened over the years, with the Irish friend even being a bridesmaid at OP’s wedding. They dreamed of their future children becoming pen pals.

A Dream Shattered

woman young teenager tired worried stressed sad guilt depressed grief troubled
image credit: F8-studio/shutterstock

The Irish friend discovered she couldn’t have kids naturally, a devastating blow given her dreams. However, she held onto hope, deciding she’d adopt when ready. Meanwhile, OP excitedly found out she was pregnant.

Celebrations on Hold

gender reveal party baby shower women pregnant
image credit: Dmytro Zinkevych/shutterstock

The global pandemic kept the Irish friend from attending the baby shower and gender reveal. Yet, she was continuously supportive and joyous for OP’s growing family. They spoke all the time about their dreams for the future.

The Naming Dilemma

pregnant woman baby shower gifts
image credit: Pixel-Shot/shutterstock

When the Irish friend inquired about baby names, OP revealed a traditional Irish name choice for her son. The friend was devastated, saying it was the name she’d always wanted for her hypothetical son.

Misguided Surprises

angry pregnant woman posing arms crossed upset
image credit: dean-drobot/shutterstock

OP’s intention behind choosing the name was to honor her friend and ask her to be the godmother. She thought it would be a touching surprise, not realizing the depth of attachment her friend had to the name.

A Connection Challenged

happy couple expecting baby
image credit: tatiana-dyubanova/canva

Upon confrontation, OP tried to justify the name choice by revealing her husband’s recent discovery of being 18% Irish through a DNA test. The Irish friend retorted that this didn’t make them genuinely Irish.

The Depth of Pain

young woman sad upset crying depressed
image credit: javier-sanz/canva

The Irish friend’s pain was palpable, especially when OP mentioned that her friend would never naturally have a child to name. The friend countered that she might adopt an unnamed baby, showing that her desire for the name remained strong.

Motivations Questioned

woman angry frustraded upset smell
image credit: khosro/canva

OP suggested the friend’s resistance might be out of jealousy or resentment. This deeply hurt her friend, leading to her abruptly ending their conversation. Immediately after, OP felt remorse for what she said.

Silence Between Friends

woman pregnant stressed upset sad
image credit: sneg17/shutterstock

The strong bond they once shared was put to the test as the Irish friend ceased all communication with OP. Every attempt to reach out was met with silence. OP did not want to lose her friend, and at the same time, she wanted to keep the baby name.

An Embroidered Dilemma

gender reveal party baby shower women
image credit: PeopleImages-Yuri-A/shutterstock

The situation grew complicated as OP’s mother had already embroidered the chosen name on blankets and newborn clothing. The name was not just a word anymore; it had become an identity for the unborn child.

A Husband’s Perspective

couple expecting baby arguing at home pregnant fight
image credit: kraken-images/shutterstock

Seeing the strained friendship, OP’s husband believed a choice was imminent: the name or the friend. But to OP, this wasn’t about a name but her son’s identity versus a hypothetical child’s name.

The Impasse

woman pregnant stressed
image credit: mykolasosiukin-canva

OP was the one who was pregnant, she reasoned, so she should be the one to choose whichever name she wants. If the situation were reversed, OP would gladly support her friend’s name.

The Emotional Tug-of-War

woman young sitting tired worried stressed sad guilt depressed grief troubled
image credit: josep-suria/shutterstock

While OP believed she was honoring her friend, the Irish woman felt her cultural identity and personal dreams were being co-opted. Both sides had genuine feelings and reasons for their perspectives.

Was The Woman’s Behavior Appropriate?

woman unsure hands to huh sides
image credit: khosro/canva

In search of unbiased opinions, OP posted her story online for feedback and perspective. The readers in the forum had a lot of mixed views on the matter.

Forum Responds

sad woman feeling tired worried about problem sitting on sofa with laptop stressed depressed teen girl
image credit: fizkes/shutterstock

One reader said, “The names you share with your best friend are off limits, end of story. No matter how the circumstances change.”

Another Commenter Thinks

poc woman happy unsure
image credit: Prostock-studio/shutterstock

Another responder wrote, “Those DNA tests are famously inaccurate, and if your husband’s only connection to his Irish heritage is the test, then I agree with your friend. He isn’t Irish!”

A Third View on The Story

male happy on computer
image: shotprime/canva

A different person stated, “Finding out you are infertile is a grieving process. You claim you’re best friends, yet this doesn’t come across in the way you write about her. In fact, the way you talk about her fertility struggles is quite cruel.”

A Final Perspective on the Matter

woman warning pointing finger
image credit: khosro/canva

Another reader commented, “Your husband is right. You’ll have to pick the name or the friendship, but it sounds like you’ve already stubbornly chosen it, even though you know it hurts her. You’re not a good friend.”

What Do You Think?

group business meeting discussion jobs
image credit: tom-merton/canva

What are your thoughts on their actions?

What would you have done in this situation?

This story is inspired by a thread from an online forum.

More From Top Dollar

angry frustrade male upset
photo credit: kurhan/shutterstock

When He Asked His Neighbors to Move Their Car From His Driveway, He Never Expected the Problem to Continue.

More From Top Dollar

worried woman
image credit: pio3/canva

She Fought Tooth and Nail to Pay Off Her Mortgage, Only to Stumble Upon a $80,000 Hurdle She Never Saw Coming.

More From Top Dollar

adult girls sisters friends siblings argue fight
image credit: kamil-macniak/shutterstock

She Asked Her Mother to Watch Her Daughter For an Afternoon, But the Day’s Events Led to a Permanent Babysitting Ban.

More From Top Dollar

young annoyed angry woman with bad attitude giving talk to hand gesture stop
image credit: esb-professional/shutterstock

She Was Excluded from a Co-worker’s Wedding, So When the Office Collected Money For a Celebratory Luncheon, She Refused to Pitch In.

More From Top Dollar

woman plane airplane flying
image credit: juice-flair/shutterstock

She Refused to Give Boss Her First-Class Seat Upgrade on the Flight Home From a Business Trip.