The Original Poster (OP) has grown increasingly skeptical of her younger brother’s claims of being colorblind, suspicions exacerbated by his frequent mentions and the family’s indulgent attitude. At a large birthday gathering, in a bid to unmask what she believes is a deception, OP devises a public test for him, leading to an unexpected revelation, and a party turned sour.
The Curious Case of Colorblindness
OP has a younger brother who started claiming to be colorblind at the age of ten. This began after a misidentification of a light pink t-shirt. Family members, including their parents, took his claim lightly, referencing a colorblind uncle in the family.
Memories of Artistic Childhood
In his younger years, OP’s brother’s drawings and paintings displayed no apparent sign of colorblindness. Colors were used appropriately, and there wasn’t a hint of any issues with perception. This only fueled OP’s skepticism regarding his brother’s later claims.
The Continuous Mention
Over the years, OP’s brother made consistent mentions of his supposed colorblindness. He spoke about it to numerous people, making it a significant part of his identity. To OP, this constant mention was an irritant, suspecting falsehood.
Disbelief and Jealousy
OP expressed doubts about her brother’s claims to their parents. However, the parents dismissed her concerns, suggesting that she might be envious of the attention her brother received. This only intensified OP’s feelings and determination to uncover the truth.
The Birthday Gathering
Last week, OP celebrated her 17th birthday with a sizable gathering. About 25-30 guests attended, including friends and family members. Inevitably, the topic of her brother’s colorblindness resurfaced.
An Impromptu Test
Amid the discussions, an irritated OP proposed an Ishihara test. This is a well-known test used to detect color blindness. With some initial reluctance, her brother agreed to the public display, confident in his disability.
OP went upstairs to fetch her computer. Her announced intention was to connect it to the TV and display the test for everyone to witness. However, privately, she had a different plan in mind to humiliate her brother.
Instead of using a genuine Ishihara test, OP presented a fake version. This was a test designed in such a way that anyone, regardless of their vision, could pass. It was a test to catch her brother in the act.
During the test, it was evident to OP that her brother pretended not to see specific numbers. He played along, indicating his inability to perceive some colors. The room watched with bated breath, awaiting the results.
Once the test ended, OP announced to everyone that the test was a complete sham. It was a trap to see if her brother would lie about his condition, which he did. This revelation changed the atmosphere entirely.
The Sour Turn
The mood of the party immediately dampened. Fury painted the faces of OP’s brother and their parents. The family awkwardly tried to defuse the situation with jokes. The gathered guests had mixed reactions.
Some of OP’s friends found the situation amusing, seeing it as a harmless prank. However, the family didn’t share this sentiment. After the guests departed, OP’s parents were seething with anger, disappointed in her actions.
Grounded for Truth
Because of her stunt, OP was grounded. Her parents labeled her as an “attention seeker” and accused her of being motivated by jealousy. The punishment was for the perceived humiliation she caused her brother.
OP, however, felt justified in her actions. She believed that if her brother had been honest, he wouldn’t have faced any humiliation. With the weight of the events on her shoulders, OP questioned if she was in the wrong.
The Moral Dilemma
While the events unfolded as they did, the underlying issue was more profound. It was a matter of truth versus belief, of validation versus trust. It was a tale of sibling dynamics and the constant quest for attention.
Was The Sister’s Behavior Appropriate?
OP posts her story online for feedback and judgment from the internet community. The readers in the forum had a lot of mixed views on the matter.
One reader said, “I have a tough time telling red and dark orange apart. However, I am not colorblind. Sounds like your bro found something that got him attention and rolled with it.”
Another Commenter Thinks
Another responder wrote, “Pathological lying, narcissism – Generally, the reason people develop these ego disorders is to compensate for their insecurity or inferiority complex.”
A Third View on The Story
A different person stated, “There wasn’t a reason to do it in front of people, especially on your birthday. This could have been something that you brought up, not in front of a bunch of people. If anything, you need to apologize to your brother and maybe do some inner thinking about why you decided to do that.”
A Final Perspective on the Matter
Another reader commented, “Yes, your brother is an annoying liar, but he wasn’t hurting anyone with it. Tricking him into revealing his benign lie is just mean and unhelpful. Eventually, his lie would have been exposed, and you wouldn’t have been responsible. Now you’ve lost the moral high ground.”